3D printing

Having a 3D-printed prototype made: process and costs

Prototyping in 3D printing: 3D-printed prototypes check form, fit and function. Process, limits, and what prototyping costs at KANID.

Date
Reading time
12 min
Author
Konstantin Vinogradov
KANID’s 3D-printed QuerLe tool in a practical test on cables

“We’ll just print that quickly” — that is how prototyping often starts. And that is right: 3D printing has made product development faster, because a part no longer sits at the toolmaker’s for weeks. But a printed part is only a good prototype if it is clear beforehand which question it is supposed to answer.

This post is about how I work with 3D-printed prototypes at KANID, what they are good for, and where their limits lie.

What is a prototype — and what is it not?

A prototype is a tool for getting rid of an uncertainty. It is not a mini-product. Typical questions a prototype answers:

The clearer the question, the simpler the prototype. For a question of fit, a section of the part is often enough, printed in a fraction of the time. For a function test, the whole assembly is needed.

Why 3D printing fits prototypes so well

The greatest advantage is the speed of the loop: design, print, test, change. Because I print in-house in Filderstadt by the FDM process, there is no shipping and no external quoting process between a design change and the printed part.

On top of that: a prototype needs no tooling. A change to the CAD model is in the next print. That makes it inexpensive to test variants side by side — for example three handle shapes or two latch variants — instead of deciding on one on the screen.

The limits of a printed prototype

An FDM part is not the same as an injection-moulded part or a milled aluminium part. That has to be kept in mind when testing:

That is why I separate two things: the 3D-printed prototype answers questions of form, fit and function. The design itself is laid out ready for manufacture, that is, so that it works in the later manufacturing process. Where strength is concerned, I check with FEM where needed, instead of relying only on the printed test.

For some products, 3D printing is also the series process. That is the case for my own products in the KANID Factory: SoloMeter, SoloMeter 2.0 and QuerLe are manufactured by FDM 3D printing from PLA in Filderstadt. Then prototype and series part are closer together, and the tests say more about the later product.

FDM, SLA or SLS — which process for which prototype?

“3D printing” is an umbrella term. For prototypes, three processes are especially common, and they do not answer the same questions equally well:

Process Strengths Limits Suitable in prototyping for
FDM fast, many materials, also larger parts visible layers, less load-bearing in the build direction, support structures on overhangs fit and assembly tests, functional and design prototypes, fixtures
SLA very smooth surface, fine detail resins often more brittle, post-processing needed appearance and design samples, small parts with fine detail
SLS load-bearing, complex geometries without support structures rough surface, usually only via a service provider loaded functional prototypes, snap hooks and joints

The choice follows the question the prototype is supposed to answer, not the process. For most questions of fit and function in development, FDM is enough. At KANID I print myself by the FDM process. If a question rather needs the surface of SLA or the load-bearing capacity of SLS, I clarify that with you before printing. What belongs to development at KANID is under Services.

3D-printed prototypes at KANID

Prototyping in 3D printing at KANID is this loop: approved CAD status, printed part, feedback into the design. The part answers a question of form, fit or function. The prototypes are made in-house in Filderstadt, by the FDM process and always together with the design. That means: whoever prints the prototype also changes the CAD model afterwards. Depending on the question I distinguish two kinds:

In the development, the prototypes are part of phase 2: material as quoted and 2 revision loops are included in the fixed price. What that costs in the fixed price of phase 2, and what is not included, is in the post Product development at a fixed price: cost and process. Answers on cost and duration are also below under “In brief”.

Functional prototypes and a small series

A functional prototype checks fit, assembly and function. A small series is several identical parts. If 3D printing is also fixed as the manufacturing process, as with SoloMeter, SoloMeter 2.0 and QuerLe, functional prototype and small series lie close together.

For customer projects that is not the offering. The development ends at the pre-series prototype. Series production, including a small series in a different process, is not included in the fixed price. With drawings, a bill of materials and STEP data you obtain quotes for that from manufacturers.

Process from the CAD status to the pre-series prototype

This is how prototyping runs in phase 2 of the development at KANID:

  1. Approve the CAD status. You review the model via a link in the browser in Onshape — without a CAD licence of your own.
  2. First prototype. I print the approved status and test it against the requirements from the Lastenheft (requirements specification).
  3. Revision loop. You review the prototype and return your change requests as a set. I work them in and hand over a revised status. Two such revision loops are included in the fixed price.
  4. Pre-series prototype. At the end stands a status that works and can be manufactured — with drawings, a bill of materials and STEP data.

The material for the prototypes as quoted is included in the fixed price of phase 2. Further revision loops only come after your prior approval. An overview of all the steps is in the post From the idea to the product.

An example from the workshop

How a prototype arises in practice is shown in the post on the drive wheel for a lawn mower: from a damaged original part and rough dimensions came a CAD model, from that a printed prototype, which was adjusted in a practical test.

It was similar with my own products. SoloMeter 2.0 arose from the first SoloMeter, with a new three-foot system and a built-in vial. The projects are on the References page, with 3D models to rotate in the browser.

What you should clarify when commissioning

If you have a prototype made in 3D printing, clarify beforehand:

The last point is the most important. A prototype without someone who turns the result into the next design is only a printed part.

In brief

What is prototyping in 3D printing at KANID?

Turning an approved CAD status into a printed part that checks form, fit or function, and feeding the result back into the design. Printing is done in-house in Filderstadt by the FDM process. Material as quoted and 2 revision loops are included in the fixed price of phase 2.

Does KANID make functional prototypes or a small series?

Functional prototypes yes, as part of the development in phase 2. A small series for customer projects, no: the development ends at the pre-series prototype; series production is not included in the fixed price. KANID manufactures its own products such as SoloMeter and QuerLe itself by FDM 3D printing, because there 3D printing is the series process.

What is a functional prototype from 3D printing?

A functional prototype checks fit, assembly and function: does the part fit the mating part, can the assembly be put together, does the clip engage, does the clamp hold? For statements about the strength or service life of a later series part from a different process, a printed part is only of limited value. There I check with FEM where needed.

What is a design prototype?

A design prototype answers questions of form and ergonomics: does the part sit well in the hand, is the button reachable, does the form look as intended? For such tests the surface of an FDM print is usually enough; for appearance samples or very tight tolerances, not always.

What do 3D-printed prototypes and prototyping cost at KANID?

In product development, 3D-printed prototypes are part of phase 2: material for the prototypes as quoted and 2 revision loops are included in the fixed price. As a guide, phase 2 starts from about 5,000 € net plus VAT for companies and from about 5,950 € incl. 19% VAT for private individuals. You receive the binding fixed price after phase 1. What the costs of prototyping and product development depend on is in the post Product development at a fixed price: cost and process.

How long does it take until the prototype?

That depends mainly on the design, less on the print. Because I print in-house, there is no shipping and no external quoting process between a design change and the printed part. Phase 1, concept and feasibility, takes about 3 to 4 weeks. An anonymised example project, a mechanical assembly for an inventor’s product, took about 12 weeks in total. That is an example, not a guide value for your project.

Which 3D-printing process does KANID use?

FDM 3D printing in-house in Filderstadt. That way there is no shipping and no external quoting process between a design change and the printed part.

What is the difference between FDM, SLA and SLS?

In the FDM process a plastic filament is melted and laid down path by path. In SLA, light cures a liquid resin layer by layer. In SLS a laser fuses plastic powder, usually polyamide. FDM is fast and versatile for fit and function, SLA delivers smooth surfaces and fine detail, SLS load-bearing parts with complex geometry and no support structures.

Which 3D-printing process is suitable for a functional prototype?

That depends on the question being checked. For fit, assembly and simple function tests, FDM is as a rule enough. If it is about appearance or fine detail, SLA fits better. If snap hooks, joints or loaded areas are to be tested closer to the later series part, SLS is often the better choice. KANID prints itself by the FDM process and clarifies before printing whether that is enough for the question being checked.

Can I just have a prototype printed, without development?

KANID’s focus is product development, that is design and prototype together. For a print job only, send a short enquiry via the contact form.

Conclusion

3D printing makes prototyping fast and inexpensive — if it is clear what is being tested, and if someone turns the result into the next design. At KANID, CAD, printing and change belong together, until the pre-series prototype is ready. What that costs is under Services. For your project, write to me via the contact form.

3D-printed prototypesprototyping in 3D printing3D-print prototypingprototypingrapid prototypinghaving a prototype madeFDMSLASLS

← Back to the overview

KANID UG
Filderstadt
Sheet
03 / 17
Rev.
Scale
1:1
Title
Blog · 3D printing
Drawing no.
KANID-WEB-2026-03
Drawn by
K. Vinogradov
Material / standard
HTML · WCAG 2.1 AA